• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Nonna Carola

Nonna Carola, a beloved Italian bar located in Mamaroneck, NY, offers a trendy, intimate, and romantic atmosphere perfect for a night out. Known for its excellent service, generous portion sizes, and flavorful dishes, Nonna Carola has become a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike. From the Aperitivo selection to the Zuppe and Insalata options, each dish is prepared with care and attention to detail. The warm bread, fresh coffee, and delectable seafood platter showcase the restaurant's commitment to quality. With a diverse menu, extensive bar offerings, and inviting ambiance, Nonna Carola truly stands out as a top dining destination in Westchester.

Nonna Carola: Reviews & Ratings

V V.
V V.

Great spot!! Its a must try !! Drinks food service was all top notch!! Im definitely going back

Amanda K.
Amanda K.

Great Italian restaurant in Mamaroneck. One of my best friends hosted her son's first birthday here and the staff was kind and attentive, the food was delicious, great drinks and ambiance. The main dining room has a nice bar and ample amount of space to host an event and there is a great outdoor area that's cozy and we'll maintained. Would definitely recommend and be back for another meal!

K E.
K E.

One of the best restaurants in Westchester. We've been here multiple times and it is always great. Beautiful restaurant, great staff. Friendly, attentive, knowledgeable and always helpful. The menu is fantastic, the food is prepared beautifully, flavors are great and portion sizes are very generous. Everything we've had has been fantastic. When bread comes warm to the table and even the coffee is actually fresh and comes to the table with warm milk you know they care. My wife's seafood platter was fantastic, my Veal Martini was great, Linguine Vongole was as fresh as can be and the whole meal was spectacular. Nonna Carola is great!

Glenn M.
Glenn M.

Very nice place, food presentation excellent and the food is great! They can accommodate larger groups (we had 9) which included 2 children. Portions are generous so bring your appetite!

Cheyenne C.
Cheyenne C.

Beautiful restaurant! Upscale feel and well decorated. Staff were very friendly and attentive. Large cocktail and wine menu, as well as food menu. Meatball app was tasty, as was the bread at the table. Pasta was super delicious and a nice portion! Had the tiramisu for dessert as well, which was great. Overall nice ambiance and place to be. On the pricier side but matches the energy and quality of the restaurant.

Marc K.
Marc K.

Service was amazing The waiter stopped by religiously every 5-10 minutes but was not hovering or annoying The ambiance outside was perfect. Clean and crisp spring air, very tidy and in order arrangement of tables and other items...uncluttered. Lighting was adequate. Tables and chairs were the outdoor type and not overly comfortable. Noise and sound ok... not hard to hear or be heard. The food was great. A delightful and generous bread basket with seasoned oil awaited us and made waiting a pleasure! The seasoning was perfect and cooked just right. Chicken was tender as was veal. The coating/crust was delicious with hints of herbs and many flavor notes. My shrimp was grilled and neither squishy nor dried out--great! The portions for the chicken and veal were generous however my salad the greens we'd not so lavish and the number of shrimp almost adequate. Heartily recommend this restaurant! IF YOU LIKE MY REVIEWS PLEASE FRIEND ME and ask to be notified!

Catherine H.
Catherine H.

Creative, delicious. Excellent service!!!!! The scalop appetizer was amazing. My seafood pasta dish cooked to perfection. A special request for no calamari in the mix, was granted with a smile. My diner guest had a wonderful fish dish piccata flare. Portions were generous. The well priced cost was appreciated, generous. We felt like we were in Italy without the effort. We will definitely go back.

Louise M.
Louise M.

A short walk from the docks (we arrived by boat) Really nice place with a great menu and both indoor and outdoor seating. Food delicious and drinks made well. Very good service. My friends had the chicken marsala, which looked absolutely delicious, and the link we need Delmar. Also a winner.

Renée C.
Renée C.

4.5 true rating First of all, we would return again if not just for the pappardelle but let me go through the important parts. There is no beer on tap but a pretty large beverage menu otherwise. There is one IPA that comes in a can and was $12. I'm sorry but that was laughable. The calamari was good. The star of the show for me was the lemon aioli. They purposely take up space on the plate with spicy peppers and for the price I really would like a fuller plate of calamari. The portion didn't make sense for the two of us. The pappardelle was fantastic. It's a delicious homemade dish and home run. Tasty, fresh, and an appropriate portion. Perhaps the quick pic I snapped doesn't even show the amount that was there. Delicious, no to-go box for me. The service and ambiance. We went on a Friday in April at 7 pm. We secured a seat outside by the fireplace with no problem. Both the inside dining area and outside dining area are very pretty and enjoyable. Nice ambiance outside and a pretty setting inside with nice lighting. It would be a fantastic first or second date or anniversary spot for anyone. It wasn't very busy and we received impeccable service. Extremely attentive with great timing.

Location

  • Nonna Carola
    211 Mamaroneck Ave Mamaroneck, NY 10543 Hotline: (914) 899-3130

Nonna Carola is a charming Italian bar located at 211 Mamaroneck Ave in Mamaroneck, NY. This trendy and intimate establishment offers a variety of amenities including reservations, wheelchair accessibility, credit card acceptance, and even cryptocurrency payment options. The ambiance at Nonna Carola is romantic and classy, making it a perfect spot for a date night or a special celebration.

As a food reviewer of Res Menu, I have had the pleasure of experiencing the delectable offerings at Nonna Carola. From their Aperitivo menu featuring options like Tagliere, PEI Mussels, and Calamari D'orati to their Zuppe and Insalata selections, each dish is crafted with care and attention to detail. The Beet Salad with arugula, red and gold beets, cherry tomatoes, goat cheese, and red vinaigrette is a standout option that combines flavors beautifully.

Customer reviews rave about the top-notch service, generous portion sizes, and flavorful dishes at Nonna Carola. Whether you're in the mood for a seafood platter, Veal Martini, Linguine Vongole, or a classic Italian dessert like tiramisu, this restaurant delivers on all fronts.

The attention to detail at Nonna Carola is evident in every aspect of the dining experience, from the warm bread that arrives at your table to the freshly brewed coffee served with warm milk. With a diverse menu, friendly staff, and elegant decor, Nonna Carola is a top choice in Westchester for those seeking an exceptional Italian dining experience.